Home Blog How to lose a high performer

How to lose a high performer

By Brad Eisenhuth | Leadership, CFO, Eisenhuth |

Most organisations are eager to attract the next high performer. Someone proactive, driven, focused, adaptable and ultimately, capable of achieving great things. 

Ironically, many organisations, and in particular, managers who aspire to building a high performance team don’t seem to know what to do when they have talent in their hands. Instead of allowing self-directed and motivated staff to thrive, they cloud, confuse and dismantle confidence with old ways of thinking. 

Here’s a list of things NOT to do if you want to retain great talent in any organisation;

Manage by exception

Let’s face it. Even the most talented and driven staff will have weaknesses. It is natural. However, driving most of your management conversation at those weaknesses is a quick way to undermine your relationship and the great things they are doing in 90% of their role. If a high achiever is creating value and a small component of their performance is not as high as others, address it in a way that ensures you don’t break the 90% of high performance you receive. Overanalysing a high performers weakness should be substituted for ways to encourage further growth and continued performance.

Changing the goal post regularly

While high performers are typical both resilient and adaptable, they are also not stupid. If you continue to waste their time by changing the game, they will inevitably want to find an environment where this doesn’t happen. If your strategy and management isn’t clear, what is a high performer going to learn from you?

Stifling their performance with your own agenda

Sometimes members of your team are going to be more motivated, driven and eager to achieve than you. That is a great thing. If you find this confronting or want to box these people in, get ready for a resignation letter.

Lacking vision

High performers are often thinking about the future. They are naturally interested in making a difference, even if they are very early in their career. If you or your company don’t have a vision that is better than where you are now, and it is questionable that this vision will be executed, then your high performer will become discouraged. In fact, if they stay around, they can become demotivated and reduce their performance.

Expecting that they are superman or superwoman

Yes, they work hard and yes, they want to do great things for their manager and their company. No, they can’t fix every problem and no, they don’t have all of the answers. They want support, engagement and leadership as much as anyone else.

Not having your sh** together

You will probably hate to admit it, but if you are a little lazy, ambiguous about your own goals or disinterested in what you are doing, other people will notice it. High performers don’t want to be around that behaviour and can find another manager or team that will be as engaged as they want to be.

Ego and history

Initially, a high performer might be inspired by your great career, where you’ve been and what you did in Company X. Eventually, this becomes boring if that’s what you rely on for credibility. Bring the thinking two years forward instead of two years back, and create some new stories with your high performers by executing something great with them.

Don't play games

High performers are usually across the detail and get what is going on around your business. Keep conversations honest about their development and if you think they are outgrowing their role and what the company can offer, then let them know. They will still respect you for the experience and continue to do the right thing as they explore an exit. 

Are you a high performer that has seen this before?






CALL US +61 2 9194 4900 


Stay in touch for free news, career tips and latest webinar alerts.

The Outperformer team is now a proud partner with B1G1, making impacts across the world every time one of our community attends a live webinar with leaders in the accounting and finance community.

Please help us continue the journey we've started.


Linkedin Facebook Twitter Instagram

Copyright © 2018 THE OUTPERFORMER Pty Ltd. All Rights Reserved. Website Design by MOBLE